Named after the nearby Esopus River, famous for fly fishing, the Esopus sits at the back of the house on the second floor and has an antique full-size bed. The Esopus’ bathroom, steps beyond its door, is shared with the Phoenicia. Booking both rooms creates a private two-bedroom space: The rooms and bathroom are blocked off from the hallway by a privacy curtain.

Rates start at $99/night + tax.